Peace and Freedom Party

California's Feminist Socialist Political Party

  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size

Vote NO on Proposition 77; Say "Yes" to real electoral reform

by Bob Richard

Proposition 77 -- the measure on the November ballot that would change the way legislative district boundaries are drawn -- isn't real election reform. The Peace and Freedom Party opposes it. But at least it gives us an opportunity to talk about what real reform would look like.

We don't need a different way of drawing boundaries around single-member districts. We need multi-member districts and proportional representation.

Proportional representation

Proportional representation means majority rule combined with representation of minority groups and political parties roughly proportional to their size. A party supported by 60 per cent of the population should have 60 per cent of the seats in legislative bodies. A group representing 10 per cent of the voters should have 10 per cent of the seats.

It's that simple, but the United States and many other countries continue to elect their legislative bodies by a different method -- one that almost guarantees that minority points of view are not adequately represented. It is called "winner-take-all", because there is only one winner in each legislative district. The winner frequently gets less than a majority of the votes.


Winner-take-all voting in single-member districts is one of the main props holding up the two-party system. This method of electing representatives generally means that only two candidates have a real chance of winning. Over time, both public opinion and the politicians are forced into one of two broad coalition -- Republicans and Democrats -- neither of which offers voters a coherent philosophy. The political map that people see shows only part of the terrain.

Even without the gerrymandering that the backers of Prop 77 claim they want to eliminate, winner-take-all elections also lead to safe seats and entrenched incumbents. In districts where voters are more evenly divided and elections are closer, the winners represent the views of fewer constituents. Winner-take-all makes competition and representation a zero-sum game.

There are a several ways to elect state legislatures and Congressional delegations that represent nearly all voters, not just those who vote for a single plurality winner. All rely on electing at least some legislators from multi-member districts.

Ways to do it

In one form of proportional representation, voters choose candidates from party lists, and each party wins seats in proportion to its share of the total vote. In another, voters choose both a candidate to represent a small single-member district and a statewide or national party list. Enough candidates are elected from each party list to ensure overall proportionality. In a third method, voters rank individual candidates in large districts that elect from 5 to 9 members each. The rankings are used to maximize the number of voters who help elect one of the winners and insure that minorities get their fair share of representation.

All of these methods do more than ensure minority representation. They also reduce or eliminate the possibility of gerrymandering, make elections more competitive, and reduce pork barrel politics.

The Peace and Freedom Party has not taken a position favoring one method of proportional representation over the others. Each has different strengths and weaknesses. But all are far better than the winner-take-all formula that is standard in the United States.

Bob Richard is a longtime Peace and Freedom Party registrant in Larkspur who is on the board of Californians for Electoral Reform.
50 Years of PFP Logo

We support ...

Preamble to Our By-laws

The Peace and Freedom Party is an open, multi-tendency, movement-oriented socialist party. We are united in our common commitment to socialism, democracy, feminism and unionism and our common opposition to capitalism, imperialism, racism, sexism and elitism.

These by-laws do not define socialism, nor do they identify the strategies and tactics of how to achieve socialism. We agree that socialism is necessary and that it will open up a democratic decision-making process for appropriate use of resources and distribution of labor.

Who's Online

We have 346 guests online



Support our campaigns!

spacing image

Donate to the Peace and Freedom Party campaign fund online by clicking the PayPal link above (PayPal membership is not required). Or make checks payable to "Peace and Freedom Party" and mail to

Peace and Freedom Party
PO Box 24764
Oakland, CA 94623

Click here for more on our fundraising campaign.

Support our voter registration drive!

Donate to the Peace and Freedom Party registration drive fund online by clicking the PayPal link above (PayPal membership is not required). Or make checks payable to "PFP Registration Drive" and mail to

PFP Reg Drive
PO Box 22234
Sacramento CA 95822

Click here for more on our registration drive.

Updates by Email

Subscribe to our email notification service and you will receive one email message each day there is an update to the front page.

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

RSS Syndication

Register to Vote

California voters can now register on line if they have a drivers license or DMV id card.
Register to vote button not available

Social Networks

Visit us on these networking and media sites.




Voter Registration

In California, voter registration is very important to political parties. The very existence of a political party as "ballot-qualified" is determined by the number of votes its statewide candidates receive or by the number of voters registered with the party. As the only feminist socialist political party on the California ballot, it is imperative that the Peace and Freedom Party continues as a qualified party. Quite simply, the Peace and Freedom Party will not be able to provide Californians with candidates that will represent us unless we register and vote Peace and Freedom.

For more information about registering to vote in California, you can visit the Secretary of State's website.